Compare · ReplyKit vs MagicReply
MagicReply and ReplyKit both draft replies on X from a Chrome extension. The differences: finding posts, three drafts, voice learning and a free start.
Pick MagicReply if
You want the simplest possible one-button reply writer and you are happy to pay from day one.
MagicReply is a Chrome extension that generates AI replies on X (Twitter) from a button in the reply box, on a paid subscription.
Pick ReplyKit if
You want help choosing which posts to answer, three drafts instead of one, replies learned from your own writing, and a free tier to test it.
Add to Chrome, free| ReplyKit | MagicReply | |
|---|---|---|
| Core job | Find posts worth replying to, then draft the reply | Draft a reply to the post you are on |
| Drafts per click | Three, each with a different angle | Typically one; see their site |
| Finding posts | Opportunity Radar badges on the X feed, free; ranked list on Pro | Not a feature, as far as their public pages show |
| Voice | Optional: learns from your own X posts; plus a writing-style note | Tone options; see their site |
| Platforms | X, LinkedIn, Reddit | X; LinkedIn is mentioned in some coverage, check their listing |
| Setup | Install, no API key, no account to start | Subscription on their site, then the extension |
| Price | Free: 10 replies on your first day, then 3 a day without an account, 5 a day with a free sign-in. Pro: €6.99/month for 1,000 replies a month plus the Radar list. | Paid subscription; current price on magicreply.io |
Our take
Written by the ReplyKit developer, so read it as such. Facts about MagicReply come from their own site. If something here is out of date, email contact@replykit.eu and it gets fixed.
This is the closest comparison on the list. Both tools sit in the X reply box and write for you. The main differences are that ReplyKit also flags which posts are worth the reply, gives three drafts instead of one, and lets you try it without paying.
Install both, reply to ten posts with each, and keep the one whose drafts you edit less. That is the only test that matters.
Built by · One person
There is no company behind this, just one developer who reads every message. If ReplyKit does not fit how you work, a feature, a platform, a different style of reply, say so. Requests from users decide what ships next.
Prefer email? contact@replykit.eu
Other comparisons